Search engine marketing

One page of results. Two entirely different purchases.

Search engine marketing is everything you do to be visible on a results page, which means the ads and the organic listings both. The two are bought differently, measured differently and fail differently, and almost every budget argument we are asked to settle comes from treating them as two versions of the same thing. They are not, and the difference is the useful part.

// The Term

Why nobody agrees what this phrase means

You will find it defined two incompatible ways in the first page of results, and both are defensible, because the phrase has moved twice in twenty years. Here is the actual history, which is more useful than being told which definition is correct.

It started as the umbrella

In the early 2000s search engine marketing meant everything you did on a search engine, paid and organic together, and search engine optimization was one activity inside it. Material from that era uses the term this way and is not wrong, it is just old.

It narrowed to mean the ads

Through the 2010s the trade press and most platforms used SEM to mean paid search specifically, largely so there was a word that meant "the part you buy" as distinct from the part you earn. This is still the most common usage in a media plan.

It has drifted back toward both

As the results page filled up with shopping units, local panels and now AI summaries, the practical question stopped being paid or organic and became which slot on this page can we occupy at all. That question needs the umbrella word back, which is why you see it used both ways.

What to do about it in a meeting

Ask which one the person means before agreeing to anything. Where it costs real money is a proposal that quotes for search engine marketing and delivers only the half you were not short of.

// Side By Side

What each half is actually good at

Not which is better. They answer different questions, and a business usually needs the one it is worse at.

PAID
What the ads are good at
What it means

Buying attention on a specific query, today, in a quantity you choose. The only lever in search that works on a deadline.

How it works
  • Live within hours of a decision
  • Volume that scales with budget
  • Exact, testable attribution per keyword
  • Control over which searches you appear for
ORGANIC
What organic is good at
What it means

Building a position that keeps producing after the work stops, and the credibility that decides whether an AI answer names you.

How it works
  • Traffic that does not stop with the budget
  • Coverage of the long tail nobody would bid on
  • Trust that a paid slot does not carry
  • Compounding value from work done once
BOTH
What only the pair can do
What it means

Occupy more than one slot on a page you are competing for, and use each side to inform the other.

How it works
  • Paid search term data feeding the content plan
  • Organic winners telling you what to bid on
  • Defending a query you rank for against rivals buying above it
  • One report where both are visible together

Different clocks · paid answers this quarter, organic answers next year, and most businesses need both answers

// The Split

How we would divide a budget, and on what basis

There is no universal ratio, and anybody who gives you one has not asked enough questions. These are the five that actually decide it.

How soon you need it to work

If revenue has to move this quarter, paid gets the larger share, because organic cannot be made to arrive on a date. If the horizon is a year or more, the weighting inverts and paid becomes the thing that keeps the lights on while the other half builds.

What a click costs in your category

In expensive categories the maths eventually stops working and organic becomes the only affordable route to volume. In cheap ones paid can carry far more of the load than people expect. Look up the real prices before deciding, not after.

Whether you already rank for the money terms

Bidding hard on queries where you hold the top organic position is often, though not always, buying a click you were about to get free. Sometimes it is worth it defensively. It should be a decision rather than a default, and it should be tested by pausing and watching.

How much of the demand is long tail

If the buying happens across thousands of specific, low-volume phrasings, no keyword list will ever cover it economically and organic does the heavy lifting. If demand concentrates in a handful of head terms, paid can own them outright.

Whether anybody is defending the AI answer

A growing share of searches now end in a summary that names a few sources and sends nobody anywhere. You cannot buy your way into that, and it is the newest argument for funding the organic side that has nothing to do with clicks.

// From the archive

A question we asked in 2010, and where it landed

One post, quoted as published, from the period when the relationship between Google's paid and organic sides was an open argument in the industry.

The question is, does Google still live up to this separation between paid and organic results?

The answer settled into a plain no in the only sense that matters to an advertiser: spending money does not buy you rankings. What did change is the page itself. Paid units, shopping panels and now AI summaries take up so much of it that the boundary between the two halves matters much less than how far down the earned result now sits.

They insist that Adwords is totally separated from organic search engine placement, that the two are in parallel channels and as such will never meet.

Still the official position and still true as stated. It is worth knowing that the separation is about the ranking systems rather than about your marketing, where the two channels meet constantly: the search terms you pay for are the best content brief you will ever get.

Around 700 posts, published since 2003

Read the archive
// Results

Numbers don't lie.

16
Case studies with published numbers
19
Client brands
12
Countries the work has run in
22
Press features
TMS Brain Health
81.8%
Of all site traffic from organic search
Monthly organic users, against March 2020
2,000%
Phone-call conversions from organic search
52%
Timeline: Mar 2020 – Jan 2023 · #1 in LA & Santa Monica for TMS therapy
Utopia Management
247
Keywords in Google's top three, across city-level local search
Organic visibility, up 12.5 points
26.61%
Of the previous year's monthly organic users
280%
Timeline: 679 local terms tracked with the map pack — and still seven times the nearest competitor in 2026
Link Building & Digital PR
DR 82
Average authority across 81 earned editorial placements
DR 90+ placements
33 of 81
Featured in
CNN · Forbes · U.S. News
Timeline: Healthline, Nasdaq, Yahoo! Finance, Seattle Times & more
Budget Trucks (budgettrucks.com.au)
440%
Organic traffic against the penalty floor — an all-time high
Weekly organic sessions under the penalty
~1,300
Weekly organic sessions after the fix
~5,700
Timeline: Oct 2011 – Nov 2014 — twelve months suppressed, then the best weeks the site had ever recorded
SNS Nails
49.92%
Organic visibility — three times the nearest competitor
Monthly organic traffic, against the starting level
440%
Keywords in Google's top three
61
Timeline: Jun 2022 – Jun 2024 — up from 3% visibility, with nothing lost or declined in the top three
Budget Rent a Car (budget.com.au)
+20.6%
Organic users, year over year — 640,088 against 530,730
Australian-locale sessions
+696%
Bounce rate on organic traffic
27.6%
Timeline: Jun–Oct 2014 against the same four months in 2013 — the audience got bigger and it got local
Selby Acoustics (selby.com.au)
24.52%
Organic visibility — first in the category, ahead of JB Hi-Fi
Keywords in Google's top three
228
Estimated organic traffic
+174%
Timeline: Aug 2023 – Aug 2026 — up 11.5 visibility points while JB Hi-Fi, Officeworks and Harvey Norman all lost ground
On Campus Marketing (rhl.org)
+61.0%
Unique visitors from organic search, year over year
Visits from non-paid search
+49.0%
Selling-season window, measured a year apart
13 days
Timeline: May 2013 against May 2012 — the move-in selling season, non-paid search only
My Site Buddy (mysitebuddy.ai)
20
Active development days for a build costed at six months of senior work
Manual estimate
820–1,060 hrs
Shipped
120+ pages
Timeline: 15 Jul – 12 Aug 2026 · 361 commits, 9 concurrent workstreams, 11 releases — every one approved by a person before production
Ross Metals (rossmetals.com)
33
Keywords at number one — gold, chain, wire and permanent jewelry
Organic visibility, up from 0.40%
15.30%
Top-three rankings lost in twelve months
0
Timeline: Jul 2025 – Aug 2026 — about 3,900 searches a month held at position one, including "wholesale gold" at $3.72 a click
Isentia (isentia.com)
+61.4%
Organic sessions, year over year
Contact form submissions
+76%
Form completion rate, up from 8.1%
10.6%
Timeline: Aug–Sep 2015 against the same weeks a year earlier, across ten markets
George Clinical (georgeclinical.com)
+286%
Monthly sessions, January 2015 to August 2018
Organic share of all sessions
57%
Contact inquiries from organic search
55%
Timeline: January 2015 to August 2018 — organic finished as the largest channel, ahead of every other source combined
Maine Cottage (mainecottage.com)
80 points
Swing in year-over-year traffic growth, inside twelve months
Year-over-year traffic at the start
-40%
Year-over-year traffic twelve months on
+40%
Timeline: Jan–Oct 2013 finished +14.7% on visits and +18.3% on unique visitors
GoPromotional (gopromotional.co.uk)
1,682
Keywords at number one in Google UK — 240% of Vistaprint, 510% of 4imprint
Keywords in the top three
2,894
Keywords on page one
4,166
Timeline: Of 8,027 tracked — first on every band, and first in the category since 2010
Expedia Japan (expedia.co.jp)
20
Brand terms at number one on Yahoo Japan — every one tracked
Brand terms at number one on Google Japan
17 of 20
Generic travel terms on page one of Yahoo Japan
17
Timeline: May 2010 — including 海外ホテル, "overseas hotels", at number one on Yahoo and number two on Google
Private Jet Charter (privatejetscharter.net)
8
Country sites run at once — and every one of them grew
Average growth across the seven country sites
+77%
Germany, the fastest of them
+123%
Timeline: Eight markets in six languages — with the localized sites holding visitors two to three times longer than the global one
// Next Steps

Arguing about the split internally?

Send us the search terms you care about and what you are spending now. We will show you where you already rank, what those clicks cost to buy, which of them you are paying for and would have had anyway, and what we would move.