Web marketing

What web marketing is, and what it is worth.

Web marketing is the practice of promoting a business through the browser — your website, search engines, email, social platforms and paid media — and measuring what each of those contributes to revenue. It is the part of marketing where attribution is genuinely possible, which is both its great advantage and the source of most of its bad decisions. We have been running it for over twenty years, since before the phrase settled down.

20 +

Years marketing on the web, from banner-era link building onward

8

Channels a full program has to cover, each with something it cannot do

20,700 +

Client keywords in Google's top three, measured in Ahrefs

7

Years the average client stays, with no long-term contract

// The Channels

The eight channels web marketing covers

Every definition of web marketing ends in a list like this one, and the list is the easy part. The question that decides whether any of it pays is which two or three you should fund this year and in what order. So each of these says what its channel is genuinely good at, and then what it cannot do — because the second half is the part that gets left out of the sales conversation and turns up later as a surprise.

Your website

Every other channel on this list ends here, which is why it is the first thing worth money. A slow or unclear page turns paid clicks into wasted spend and organic rankings into bounces, and no amount of traffic fixes it. What it cannot do is create demand. A site is where a decision gets made, not where it starts.

Search engine optimization

Earning organic positions for the queries your buyers already type. The slowest channel to start and the cheapest to run once it works, because you stop paying by the click and the asset keeps producing. It also feeds the AI answer engines, since they read organic results before deciding who to quote. What it cannot do is produce results this quarter. Anyone who says otherwise is describing a paid campaign.

Paid search and shopping

Google Ads and Microsoft Ads buy you the top of the page today, at a price per click that rises with the competition. The right channel when you need inquiries this month, when you want to test whether a message converts before committing a year of content to it, or when the organic result is genuinely out of reach. What it cannot do is compound. The day the card stops, so does the traffic.

Content

The pages that answer what your buyers ask before they are ready to buy. Content is what SEO ranks, what email has to carry, what social distributes and what an AI engine quotes, which is why treating it as a channel in its own right usually disappoints and treating it as the raw material the others run on usually does not. What it cannot do is work at volume without a point of view. Nobody links to, quotes or remembers the fourth article that says the same thing.

Digital PR and link building

Earned coverage on publications your buyers and Google both already trust. This is the authority half of search, and the half that cannot be shortcut, because search engines and language models alike weigh what other people say about you far above what you say about yourself. What it cannot do is run in bursts. A campaign that stops after a quarter leaves a profile that looks exactly like a campaign that stopped after a quarter.

Email

The only channel here you own outright. No platform can change an algorithm and cut your reach overnight, which is why cost per conversion on a maintained list stays below anything you rent. What it cannot do is find you new people. Its ceiling is the size of your list, so it is a compounding channel rather than a starting one, and a business with no other channel running has nothing to compound.

Social

Distribution and proof more than direct response, for most considered purchases. It puts work in front of people who are not searching yet, and it is how a buyer checks whether the company is real before they call. What it cannot do is be judged on follower counts. If the reporting on it does not show assisted conversions, the channel is not being measured, it is being admired.

Analytics and conversion rate optimization

The feedback loop that tells the other seven what to do next. Lifting the conversion rate of a page costs less than doubling the traffic to it and makes every channel above worth proportionally more. What it cannot do is rescue a weak offer. It is also where the reporting most often goes quietly wrong, which the next section is about.

// Measurement

Web marketing is measurable. That is not the same as measured.

The oldest argument for marketing on the web is that, unlike a half-page advert in a trade magazine, you can count it. That argument is correct, and it is also where most programs come apart, because the things easiest to count are rarely the things that pay. These are the four failures we find most often when we take over a report someone else was writing.

Traffic is not the number

Sessions are the metric every dashboard leads with and the one least connected to revenue. A campaign can double traffic and halve inquiries by attracting the wrong half of a market. The number worth putting at the top of a report is whatever the business counts as a lead, and then the cost of one, by channel.

Averages hide the whole story

Site-level averages are the most common reason a working program gets canceled in month four. Keywords enter the index deep, climb through the position bands, and pay only once they reach the top few results — so an average position that barely moves can sit on top of a large migration upward. We report counts of distinct keywords per band, branded split from non-branded, weighted by volume. It takes longer to read and it shows you what is actually happening.

The tools disagree with each other

Ahrefs, Semrush and DataForSEO have each been out by up to three times against the others on the same metric for the same site in the same month — we have the working to hand. Any figure that matters gets cross-checked against Search Console and against a second tool before it goes in a report, and single-month comparisons get thrown out entirely, because they produced two flatly wrong conclusions the last time anyone trusted one.

Impressions are not demand

The most expensive mistake on this list. A keyword can show tens of thousands of impressions in Search Console and have almost no real search volume behind it, because Google is bucketing many variants under one label. We screen every target against its actual volume before it goes on a plan, and against the live result page for whether the page is transactional at all. Skipping that check once put a dictionary term at the top of a target list and overstated what the list was worth by a quarter.

Some of it never touches the web

The customer who found you through search, read three pages, and then rang the number or walked into the shop is invisible to analytics by default, and in most businesses they are the majority. Call tracking, offline conversion imports and asking new customers where they came from are unglamorous, and without at least one of them the attribution is confidently wrong rather than roughly right.

Not everything worth doing is measurable this quarter

Brand searches, direct traffic and being the name someone already has in mind are produced by work that no single-touch model will ever credit. The honest version of measurement includes saying which parts of a program are being judged on evidence and which are being judged on judgment, rather than quietly attributing the second to the first.

// Process

How a program actually gets built

Not a list of everything we could do. Four stages, in this order, because the order is what most of the value is.

Find out what is already working

Before anything is proposed: where you rank and where you do not, which channels are producing the inquiries you already get, what your three closest competitors are winning on, and which of your current spend has no attribution attached to it at all. This stage regularly ends with us recommending less than the client expected to buy, because something they already own is underused.

Data in →

Fix the destination first

Every channel points at the site, so the site sets the ceiling on all of them. Speed, clarity, the path from landing to inquiry, trust signals visible without scrolling, and the tracking that will tell you whether any of the rest worked. Spending on traffic before this is done is paying full price for a discount result.

Strategy →

Buy demand while you earn it

Paid search runs first because it produces inquiries and, more usefully, evidence: within weeks it tells you which messages convert and which keywords are worth a year of organic work. That evidence then aims the slow half, meaning content, SEO and digital PR, so the compounding channels get pointed at something proven rather than something assumed. The paid budget comes down as the organic positions arrive, and not before.

Execute →

Report so a slow quarter is visible

Position bands rather than averages, branded split from non-branded, cost per inquiry by channel, and an explicit note on what is not yet attributable. A report built this way will sometimes show you a quarter where the leading indicators moved and the revenue did not, which is exactly the quarter a summary would have hidden and the one you most need to see.

∞ Loop
// Straight Answers

The questions we get asked about web marketing

These are the ones that come up in a first call, answered the way we would answer them on the phone.

What is meant by web marketing?

Promoting a business through things a customer reaches in a browser: your website, search engines, email, social platforms and paid media, run together and measured against what the business actually sells. The definition matters less than the boundary it draws. Everything inside it can be attributed to some degree, which is why it gets budget and why it gets argued about.

Is web marketing the same as digital marketing?

In everyday use, yes — along with internet marketing and online marketing, which are the same term in different decades. The one distinction worth keeping is that digital marketing is the wider category and also covers SMS, in-app advertising, connected TV and digital billboards, none of which involve a browser. Web marketing is the browser-based part, which is where the great majority of a mid-market budget goes. Anyone drawing a sharper line than that is usually selling the line.

How do you start web marketing?

With whichever channel your buyers already use, pointed at a site that can convert them. In practice that is nearly always the website first, then search — paid to find out what converts, organic to stop paying for it. Social and email earn their place once there is something worth distributing and a list worth writing to. Starting with five channels at once is the most common way a first-year budget disappears without producing evidence about any of them.

How much does web marketing cost?

Two separate numbers that get conflated constantly. There is media spend, which goes straight to Google or Meta and is yours. Separately there is the cost of the work, whether that is a salary, a freelancer or a retainer. Ours is a flat monthly fee with no long-term contract, and the mix inside it moves with what the data says rather than with what was scoped in month one. We would rather quote it against your numbers than publish a table that fits nobody.

How long before it works?

Paid search can produce inquiries in the first week. Organic search typically shows movement in the position bands within a quarter and clicks in the second or third, because keywords climb before they pay. Digital PR lands its first placements in weeks and its effect on rankings a good deal later. If a proposal promises organic results in thirty days, it is either describing paid traffic or describing a site that was under a penalty.

Does web marketing still work now that AI answers the question?

It works differently, and this is the largest change to the subject in a decade. A growing share of searches end in an AI Overview or a chat window with no click at all, so ranking and being found have come apart — you can hold position three and lose the customer to a summary that quoted somebody else. What matters now is whether you are the source the model names, which depends on relevance, authority and whether a machine can lift a clean answer out of your page. Our SEO and AI search page sets out the whole framework.

Can we run this in-house?

Parts of it, and the parts that work in-house are the ones needing product knowledge more than tooling: the content, the email, the social, the knowing what customers actually ask. The parts that go wrong in-house are the ones where the feedback loop is long and the tools mislead — technical SEO, link acquisition and paid account structure, where a mistake takes two quarters to show up and looks like bad luck when it does. Most of the best arrangements we are in are a mix of the two rather than a handover.

Can you give an example of web marketing?

A concrete one, and it is the ordinary shape of the work. A buyer searches a problem, finds a page that answers it because that page was written for the question, does not inquire, sees the company again in a trade publication a fortnight later, joins the mailing list, and calls two months after that. Four channels contributed, one click is attributable, and the case studies below are that pattern running for years rather than months.

// From the archive

We were writing about this when it was called internet marketing

Eleven passages from our own archive, verbatim, with the dates on them. The tools named in them are gone and some of the numbers have aged badly. The arguments are the ones we still have with clients most weeks.

Many internet entrepreneurs have an idea, they have a product, they have a website, but they typically still fail because they do not have the internet marketing savvy. They need a plan on how to get people to visit their website, how to ensure these people are looking for exactly what it is they are currently trying to sell, and to make sure once the visitor arrives at their website they are presented with a website which will provide them with the information, tools, overall navigation structure and calls to action to make sure they buy the product while they are visiting.

I know this sounds like a lot of work, but these are all so important to the success of your product or service online. Great products, great prices, great service do not sell online alone; great internet marketing offers you the opportunity to present your potential customers or clients with the great products, services and prices that you have to offer.

Seventeen years on, still the argument for treating this as one program rather than a set of purchases. Traffic, intent and the page that receives them are three parts of one sentence, and a business buying only the first is buying the least useful third of it.

SEO's like me tend to approach business completely backwards from what is traditional. Give me any product, as long as the demand is good, and some decent profit margins, and our mind is racing ahead with marketing and getting traffic! (very targeted traffic).

That is John, and it is still roughly how the first conversation goes. Starting from demand that already exists rather than from the product you happen to have is the one part of this discipline that has not changed at all in twenty years.

Most internet users find organic search results much more relevant than paid search advertisements, but "most" doesn't mean 90% - it's more like 61%. In other words, nearly 40% find paid search ads more relevant than organically generated ones. This means that paid search versus organic search isn't so much an either / or proposition as it is a "how much SEO versus how much paid placement" proposition.

The 61% comes from a 2004 study and should not be quoted at anyone today. The reframing in the last sentence outlived it completely, and it is why the channel section above is written as a mix rather than a ranking. The question has since grown a third term: how much paid, how much organic, and how much of the work that decides whether a model names you at all.

Here's an analogy. Have you ever been shopping in the springtime for plants for your garden and marveled at the selection of tall, bright flowers that are already blooming? Chances are good that the nursery they came from added lots of fertilizer of the type designed to produce lots of quick growth and blooming. The thing is, the root structure isn't always that great, so you have to be careful transplanting them so that you'll get good root growth, because without good roots, those early forced blooms will fade quickly and not be replaced with the kind gained from long-term care.

Your paid search results can get you some quick growth right off the bat, but if you don't have the root structure of good content, frequent updating, and smart use of keywords and tags, those paid results can't prop you up for very long. Sure, you can always start a new advertising campaign to goose your site's ranking, but that alone isn't enough to get you steady, sustained growth over the long term. It's not an either / or proposition: both are necessary for the best results.

This is the sequencing stage above, written before we had a name for it. One correction: an advertising campaign does not goose a site's ranking and never did. That was a common belief in 2010 and Google has been clear since that the two systems do not touch. Everything either side of it still holds.

So now that you're looking at the list of words with exact match, you will see some columns that display how competitive each keyword is. For the most part this is completely useless as in most of the verticals we have worked in, all of the words anyone would want to rank for are displayed as very competitive, therefore having the little green bar nailed all the way to the right. The only way to use this info is when you see words which are not currently shown as competitive and have a reasonable amount of search traffic, you've found a fantastic potential target.

The green bar is long gone and the complaint transferred straight onto its replacements. Every difficulty score sold today has the same problem at the top of a competitive category, and the same use: it is worth reading only when it disagrees with you.

If your just getting onto the game, the likelihood of getting to page one any time soon for your trophy terms is quite low, so realize that this lower hanging fruit using these popular two and three word search query phrases are going to be your life blood for the next 12-18 months.

Typo and all, this is the timescale conversation we still have most weeks, and the twelve to eighteen months has not moved. What has moved is that the tail is now also where an AI answer goes looking, so the lower hanging fruit pays twice.

Keep in mind that people read screens about one-quarter slower than they do a printed page, and that screen reading is harder on the eyes. Keep the fonts at 10 or 12 point size. Internal links will let your readers jump to the parts of the page they're interested in. If your external links open in a new window, let your reader know. Some users flip out when they click a link and suddenly windows are opening everywhere.

The point sizes are of their time and everything else is a usability checklist that has quietly become an SEO one. Descriptive anchor text and internal links that let a reader jump are now read by the machines as well, which was not the reason we wrote them down.

We're interested in is converting Web site visitors to leads that may mean a true increase in business. People have invested money in the pursuit of increased traffic to their Web sites but sometimes don't go one step further and generate quality leads. This is the major step you need to take to have an effective Web site and to measure site effectiveness.

Typo and all, this is the single most common problem we are still called about. A business buys traffic, the traffic arrives, and nobody ever funded the step that turns it into anything. Sixteen years of better tooling has not made that mistake any less popular.

The simple answer is: You need to know your Web site's conversion rate. The information must be a current, accurate report on such ratios as visitor-to-lead, lead-to-sale and visitor-to-client. Some successful online businesses consider this last ratio the most important because it tracks the cold-call visitor through the process and shows which of these visitors become long-term customers.

Visitor-to-client is still the ratio that settles arguments, and still the one least likely to be on a dashboard. Everything upstream of it can look healthy while it stays flat, which is exactly the situation the measurement section above is about.

Your content should start with the conclusion. If you write your pages so that you build up to a whammo conclusion, nobody will read it because they won't get that far. This isn't Walden, and you're not Henry David Thoreau. You want to start out with the big news and then go into the details. The phrase "above the fold" is even more important to web readers than newspaper readers.

Written for human readers with short attention spans, and it turns out to be the rule that now decides whether a language model can lift an answer out of your page at all. Put the answer in the first fifty words. Nobody in 2010 knew that was going to matter twice.

If you hire a freelancer or go through an agency, it is important to clearly define an initial job for the writer. Try to be as specific as possible as to tone, topic, length, and how densely keywords or key phrases need to be included. Consider their first assignment a test run and see how well it meshes with your needs.

The keyword density part has expired. The rest is the brief we still write, and the test-run instinct matters more now than it did then, because the thing you are checking for is whether a person wrote it.

Around 700 posts, published since 2003

Read the archive
// Services

The services behind it

Web marketing is the program. These are the disciplines it is assembled from, and they are how we are organized — a client on a full program is buying several of these with one plan across them, not six retainers that report separately.

Web Development

Custom applications, AI-powered tools, and modern web platforms. From headless architectures to agentic workflows — we build what moves your business forward.

React WordPress PHP E-Commerce APIs Agentic AI Headless CMS Laravel
Avg. Performance
98/100

SEO

Technical audits, content strategy, and link building — plus the answer engines now sitting on top of them. Over 20,700 client keywords in Google's top three.

Keyword Rankings 400%Avg. ROI

Conversion Optimization

A/B testing, user behavior analysis, and funnel optimization. Turn existing traffic into more revenue.

90%
CVR Lift
Avg. across clients

Web Marketing

Integrated campaigns that drive awareness, engagement, and conversions across every channel that ends on your website.

Channels Covered
Content Social Email Brand Analytics Reporting
// Go Deeper

Four more pages on this

This page is the whole subject at once. These go narrow: two on the terms people search and what has happened to the advice under them, two on buying the work rather than doing it.

Internet marketing

The older name for the same job. What survived the last twenty years and what died — including the click-through figures everyone still quotes, which are ours and are sixteen years out of date.

/internet-marketing/

Website marketing

Two jobs under one phrase: getting the site found, and getting the visit to count. Most businesses fund one and assume the other. There is a quick test for which.

/website-marketing/

Web marketing services

What you are actually buying, what a month of it looks like, what falls outside a retainer, and the six questions that tell you whether a scope document means anything.

/web-marketing-services/

Web marketing agency

How to choose one, including how to rule us out. Eight questions to ask, and the red flags we published in 2010 that have not needed updating since.

/web-marketing-agency/

Pinterest measurement

Why an old button-event workaround is not a current measurement plan, and what to measure instead.

/2012/05/14/tracking-pins-with-the-pinterest-button/

Brand promotion on TikTok

Commercial disclosure, music rights, creative testing and the business action behind the view count.

/2020/06/30/5-ways-to-promote-your-brand-on-tik-tok/

Mind mapping for planning

Choose a visual-thinking tool by the decision, research or workshop it has to support.

/2020/12/30/best-mind-mapping-tools-for-visual-thinking/

Four Free Analytics Tools

A 2026 update that assigns Search Console, analytics and event tracking distinct jobs before a report informs a decision.

/2010/02/16/four-free-analytics-tools/
// Results

Numbers don't lie.

16
Case studies with published numbers
19
Client brands
12
Countries the work has run in
22
Press features
TMS Brain Health
81.8%
Of all site traffic from organic search
Monthly organic users, against March 2020
2,000%
Phone-call conversions from organic search
52%
Timeline: Mar 2020 – Jan 2023 · #1 in LA & Santa Monica for TMS therapy
Utopia Management
247
Keywords in Google's top three, across city-level local search
Organic visibility, up 12.5 points
26.61%
Of the previous year's monthly organic users
280%
Timeline: 679 local terms tracked with the map pack — and still seven times the nearest competitor in 2026
Link Building & Digital PR
DR 82
Average authority across 81 earned editorial placements
DR 90+ placements
33 of 81
Featured in
CNN · Forbes · U.S. News
Timeline: Healthline, Nasdaq, Yahoo! Finance, Seattle Times & more
Budget Trucks (budgettrucks.com.au)
440%
Organic traffic against the penalty floor — an all-time high
Weekly organic sessions under the penalty
~1,300
Weekly organic sessions after the fix
~5,700
Timeline: Oct 2011 – Nov 2014 — twelve months suppressed, then the best weeks the site had ever recorded
SNS Nails
49.92%
Organic visibility — three times the nearest competitor
Monthly organic traffic, against the starting level
440%
Keywords in Google's top three
61
Timeline: Jun 2022 – Jun 2024 — up from 3% visibility, with nothing lost or declined in the top three
Budget Rent a Car (budget.com.au)
+20.6%
Organic users, year over year — 640,088 against 530,730
Australian-locale sessions
+696%
Bounce rate on organic traffic
27.6%
Timeline: Jun–Oct 2014 against the same four months in 2013 — the audience got bigger and it got local
Selby Acoustics (selby.com.au)
24.52%
Organic visibility — first in the category, ahead of JB Hi-Fi
Keywords in Google's top three
228
Estimated organic traffic
+174%
Timeline: Aug 2023 – Aug 2026 — up 11.5 visibility points while JB Hi-Fi, Officeworks and Harvey Norman all lost ground
On Campus Marketing (rhl.org)
+61.0%
Unique visitors from organic search, year over year
Visits from non-paid search
+49.0%
Selling-season window, measured a year apart
13 days
Timeline: May 2013 against May 2012 — the move-in selling season, non-paid search only
My Site Buddy (mysitebuddy.ai)
20
Active development days for a build costed at six months of senior work
Manual estimate
820–1,060 hrs
Shipped
120+ pages
Timeline: 15 Jul – 12 Aug 2026 · 361 commits, 9 concurrent workstreams, 11 releases — every one approved by a person before production
Ross Metals (rossmetals.com)
33
Keywords at number one — gold, chain, wire and permanent jewelry
Organic visibility, up from 0.40%
15.30%
Top-three rankings lost in twelve months
0
Timeline: Jul 2025 – Aug 2026 — about 3,900 searches a month held at position one, including "wholesale gold" at $3.72 a click
Isentia (isentia.com)
+61.4%
Organic sessions, year over year
Contact form submissions
+76%
Form completion rate, up from 8.1%
10.6%
Timeline: Aug–Sep 2015 against the same weeks a year earlier, across ten markets
George Clinical (georgeclinical.com)
+286%
Monthly sessions, January 2015 to August 2018
Organic share of all sessions
57%
Contact inquiries from organic search
55%
Timeline: January 2015 to August 2018 — organic finished as the largest channel, ahead of every other source combined
Maine Cottage (mainecottage.com)
80 points
Swing in year-over-year traffic growth, inside twelve months
Year-over-year traffic at the start
-40%
Year-over-year traffic twelve months on
+40%
Timeline: Jan–Oct 2013 finished +14.7% on visits and +18.3% on unique visitors
GoPromotional (gopromotional.co.uk)
1,682
Keywords at number one in Google UK — 240% of Vistaprint, 510% of 4imprint
Keywords in the top three
2,894
Keywords on page one
4,166
Timeline: Of 8,027 tracked — first on every band, and first in the category since 2010
Expedia Japan (expedia.co.jp)
20
Brand terms at number one on Yahoo Japan — every one tracked
Brand terms at number one on Google Japan
17 of 20
Generic travel terms on page one of Yahoo Japan
17
Timeline: May 2010 — including 海外ホテル, "overseas hotels", at number one on Yahoo and number two on Google
Private Jet Charter (privatejetscharter.net)
8
Country sites run at once — and every one of them grew
Average growth across the seven country sites
+77%
Germany, the fastest of them
+123%
Timeline: Eight markets in six languages — with the localized sites holding visitors two to three times longer than the global one
// Testimonials

What people say about working with us

We have been working with John and Web Moves for 14 years and the results have been astounding. John is a straight shooter — if he says he can do it, you can be confident he will deliver.
S

Shaun O'Brien

Owner, Selby Acoustics

Shaun was John's client

The great thing about John is his honesty — he tells it like it is. He is respected by major players including Microsoft and eBay, and media seek out his views: the front page of the Wall Street Journal among them.
P

Phil Leahy

Founder, MedCart Marketplace & Retail Global Events

Phil was John's client

John is the single most knowledgeable individual in the SEO industry I have ever worked with. Whether as a client, vendor or business partner, I cannot recommend him more highly.
M

Matthew Kligerman

Building Dirt — AI land development platform

John was Matthew's client

// Questions

Frequently asked questions

What does web marketing actually cover?

Content, social, email, brand and reporting, plus the search and paid work when they belong to the same plan. It is a category rather than a single channel, which is why it is described by what it covers rather than by one return figure. A single number across that spread would describe none of it.

How do you decide which channels to fund?

By what the evidence supports rather than by what is fashionable. Paid search shows which queries carry buying intent, organic shows where durable demand sits, and earned coverage shows what your sector will actually publish. Channels that cannot show their work get cut.

How is this different from just doing SEO?

SEO is one channel inside it. Web marketing is the decision about which channels deserve budget next year, and the reporting that makes that decision checkable afterwards.

What does reporting look like?

Plain English, monthly, and keyword by keyword rather than as a site-level average. Averages hide the thing worth seeing, which is how many terms moved between position bands and which of those carry commercial intent.

// Next Steps

Not sure which two channels are worth funding next year?

Send us your site and the three competitors who beat you most often. We will come back with where each of you is winning, which channels are actually producing their traffic, where the cheapest ground is, and what we would leave alone — before anyone talks about a retainer.